On Nov. 3, City of Miami voters turned down a long-running proposal to hand the Rickenbacker and Marine Stadium marinas on Virginia Key to a private developer. On the same ballot, they approved a $450 million bond for public safety buildings. Neither result moves a condo price overnight, but both shape the waterfront and city services around some of Miami’s most valuable addresses, from Brickell to Key Biscayne.
What happened
The marina question, Referendum 3, asked voters to approve a lease of roughly 27 to 28 acres of city-owned waterfront on Virginia Key to Virginia Key LLC, a partnership of RCI Group and Suntex Marinas. According to WLRN’s pre-election explainer, the deal would have run 45 years with two 15-year renewal options, for up to 75 years. The city would have received at least $2.2 million a year in rent plus 6% of revenues. The plan called for consolidating the public and private marinas into one privately run operation, with restaurants, bars, shops and a waterfront center. Bisnow put the planned work at about $80 million, including boat storage.
The unusual part is how it got on the ballot. The terms date back to a 2016–2017 bid. The city later cancelled the award, the developer sued, and courts found the city had acted improperly, which meant the lease had to go to voters, as Miami requires for waterfront leases. Commissioners placed it on the ballot reluctantly, and city leaders argued the decade-old terms no longer matched today’s property values.
Voters agreed. WLRN reported a resounding “no,” and Bisnow put the rejection at about 65%. The development group has said it still wants to pursue the project, so this may not be the last word on Virginia Key.
The same ballot approved the “Safe & Ready” bond: $450 million to repair and modernize fire stations, build four new stations and create a new police and fire headquarters. A separate measure creating an independent oversight committee for bond projects also passed.
What it means for buyers
- Virginia Key stays as it is, for now. The marinas sit along the Rickenbacker Causeway, the only road link between the mainland and Key Biscayne. A large private build-out there would have meant years of construction near that corridor. That is off the table for the moment.
- Waterfront in Miami is hard to change. Public waterfront leases need a citywide vote, and voters have shown they will say no. For buyers, that supports the long-term value of existing water views and bay access, because large new waterfront projects on public land face a high bar.
- Watch the bond rollout. New and upgraded fire stations are a long-term service improvement. Bonds are repaid over time, so ask how debt service could show up in future city budgets, alongside the homestead changes from Amendment 3.
What it means for owners and sellers
For Key Biscayne owners, the result keeps the drive across Virginia Key familiar and avoids a long construction period on the causeway approach. For boat owners in Brickell and on the Key, nearby slip supply stays as it is for now, though no upgrade is coming soon either.
City of Miami owners in Brickell, Downtown, Edgewater, Coconut Grove and elsewhere will see the safety bond play out over several years. It is worth tracking which stations get rebuilt first, since response infrastructure is part of what buyers and insurers look at.
Note that these were City of Miami votes. Key Biscayne, Miami Beach, Coral Gables and other municipalities had their own ballot questions, and Coral Gables voters, for example, approved a measure requiring a 60% vote before the city can sell or lease park land.
Our take
The pattern across Miami-Dade this election was clear: voters want a direct say before public land, especially waterfront and parks, is leased or sold. That tends to protect existing view corridors and green space, which quietly supports values in established waterfront neighborhoods. It also means anyone counting on a specific public-land project to lift a nearby building’s prices should treat that upside as uncertain.
For Virginia Key in particular, the developer’s interest and the city’s position that the old terms were too cheap suggest the site will come back up in some form. If you own or are buying on Key Biscayne or along the Brickell waterfront, it is worth keeping an eye on the next proposal.
If you want to stay on top of buildings in these neighborhoods, sign up for Building Alerts on any building page, or call or text Abraham Ash at (305) 586-9734, Coldwell Banker Global Luxury.
Sources
- WLRN: Miami rejects controversial marina plan, votes up $450 million safety bond
- WLRN: Miami officials think the Virginia Key marina referendum is a ‘bad deal.’ So why is it on the ballot?
- Bisnow: How South Florida voted on local CRE ballot measures
Considering a Move in Miami?
For discreet, strategic guidance on buying or selling luxury homes and condominiums in Miami, speak with Abraham directly.
Contact Abraham Ash
